Most disappointing/best manga turned anime?

well, both formats of media have their merits. Manga is great at making the audience ponder and thinks for themselves, which increases the suspense and drama; while anime is more engaging and action packed.

Thus, drama and romance are usually better in manga (although white album 2nd season anime kicked ass), and action series are usually more awe-inspiring in animated form (e.g. Gurren Lagann).

I once read Love Hina... I think there were to many random stories.
Don't misunderstand, I thought the stories were really good and I had fun reading them, but it just were to many after all.
All in All thought the Manga was awesome, cool, interesting, etc.

However after i finished Love Hina (Needed all in all 4 days ... ^^) I dared to watch the Love Hina anime because I was interested myself and a friend said it's good.

I've never finished it. To be true I did only watch the first 3 episodes of it. I stopped looking cause there was a random guy, I've never seen in the Manga, crashing with an Helicopter into the inn and babbling about being in love with Naru. o_O
Then after that Haru even flew with him to school o_O She never would have done it in the Manga o_O

After that my desire for that, no, for every Anime was shattered to pieces....
That was a year ago I think. Till yesterday I've never again watched an Anime

To me I usually consider if the manga was original, and adapted into an anime, then the manga is usually better. I feel the same way with an original anime.

joezilla87 wrote:To me I usually consider if the manga was original, and adapted into an anime, then the manga is usually better. I feel the same way with an original anime.

I share this opinion.
The only exception I know is Bleach

zijian wrote:Thus, drama and romance are usually better in manga (although white album 2nd season anime kicked ass), and action series are usually more awe-inspiring in animated form (e.g. Gurren Lagann).

oh fuck yes. ttgl was the sickest shit ever. i cant believe theres a manga version. its definitely not gonna be as good

joezilla87 wrote:To me I usually consider if the manga was original, and adapted into an anime, then the manga is usually better. I feel the same way with an original anime.

the FMA manga was kind of disappointing. shitty artwork, but im not sure which came first lol

The manga came out first. I've seen some episodes of FMA but I haven't read the manga yet. I liked anime and I think its a pretty good story so I might start reading the manga soon.

Peanut wrote:I once read Love Hina... I think there were to many random stories.
Don't misunderstand, I thought the stories were really good and I had fun reading them, but it just were to many after all.
All in All thought the Manga was awesome, cool, interesting, etc.

However after i finished Love Hina (Needed all in all 4 days ... ^^) I dared to watch the Love Hina anime because I was interested myself and a friend said it's good.

I've never finished it. To be true I did only watch the first 3 episodes of it. I stopped looking cause there was a random guy, I've never seen in the Manga, crashing with an Helicopter into the inn and babbling about being in love with Naru. o_O
Then after that Haru even flew with him to school o_O She never would have done it in the Manga o_O

After that my desire for that, no, for every Anime was shattered to pieces....
That was a year ago I think. Till yesterday I've never again watched an Anime

same here... love hina's anime was such a let down compared to the manga i stopped after like 5 episodes and re-read the manga lol

though the best manga-anime for me was history's strongest disciple... if i recall correctly everything was almost exact.

For me, rosario + vampire anime was most disappointing. Not that it was bad, it was good in its own respect but all the action from the manga that I was expecting was missing from it.

The best for me is cross game. The anime closely follows the story and is as good as manga.

I haven't even heard about the Manga / Anime you're talking about
Gotta look at them ^^